I lived in Australia for 35 years. At election time, I usually voted for a minority party that reflected my true beliefs In other words, whatever one was the greenest. At the same time, I knew that one of the other of the two main parties would almost certainly win. And I definitely had a preference for one of those (the Australian Labor Party) over the other.
Under the Australian system of preferential voting, I could express my loyalty to the party of my choice by voting for them. And at the same time I could indication my preference for the ALP. So that if it was a tight election, my vote would still count. In other words, my vote truly did express what I wanted.In full.
Here in England, under the FPTP system, if I vote for my party of first choice (the Green Party), which has a snowball's chance in hell of winning in my constituency, then in terms of the battle of Labour vs Conservative, mine is a wasted vote. I have no way, here, of expressing my full wishes. I am hobbled.
The UK Tories are telling people that Australians don't like their system. I believe that is a total lie. In all my 35 years there I never once heard anyone express a wish to switch to a FPTP ballot. A lot of people - including me - did say that proportional representation, like many European countries have, would be an even better way to choose a government. And maybe we'll even manage that, eventually. Meanwhile...
Brits are a conservative bunch and don't take kindly to change. I can hardly dare to hope that they will flock to the polls tomorrow to vote 'YES' and change this antiquated and unfair system to a fairer, more flexible and more democratic one. But oh, it would be so wonderful if they did!
Wednesday, May 04, 2011
6 comments:
Message from Marian: I love to get your feedback. So please don't be put off by the fact that I am now screening all comments before they are posted. I had to do this, as I was getting too many spam comments.
Also, please don't worry if your comment doesn't appear for a while. (I am sometimes travelling and unable to access the Internet).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Damn straight. I shall be there with my "yes" hat on!
ReplyDeleteyep me too :)
ReplyDeleteUs too!
ReplyDeleteMarian, we have just elected our first green member to the federal parliament here in Canada, and I was so happy - thought the day would never come. of course, the new government is Tory, but at last we Greens are on our way, and Elizabeth May will make a fine representative in the house.
ReplyDeleteThat's great news, Cate.
ReplyDeleteNeedless to say the 'no' vote won here (sigh).
I lived in the U.K. from '70 to '83 but after much thought (it took me more than a year to decide) I moved my family to the U.S., mostly because I didn't want them caught in the cross-fire of the class war.
ReplyDeleteIt seemed like the right move at the time but now I'm not so sure.